According to the official study materials, what third verdict was possible in a Scottish criminal trial?
Correct Answer
Not proven
Explanation: In Scotland, a third verdict of 'not proven' was also possible. (This is the answer in the official study materials. The 'not proven' verdict was abolished on 1 January 2026 under the Victims, Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Act 2025.)
⚡ ADHD Brain Hack (Memory Mnemonic)
This question has a Brain Hack — a short memory hook built to make the answer stick on the first read.
Reveal it free in the app →Exam Question Options
- Guilty but insane
- Not proven
- Pardon
- Undecided
Why the other options are wrong
- Guilty but insane
- 'Guilty but insane' was a special verdict used in England from 1883 to 1964, never one of Scotland's three verdicts.
- Pardon
- A pardon is granted by the Crown after a conviction, so a jury can't return it as a verdict.
- Undecided
- Scottish juries don't return 'undecided': if not enough jurors vote guilty, the accused is acquitted.
Background
'Not proven' was a full acquittal with the same legal effect as 'not guilty', so Scottish juries could return guilty, not guilty or not proven. It is the answer the official study materials give, but it was abolished for trials starting on or after 1 January 2026 by the Victims, Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Act 2025. A guilty verdict now needs at least 10 of the 15 jurors.